Which leaves two main ways to enjoy this story:
1. The BBC Audio: The surviving soundtrack, cleaned up with some linking narration by Frazer Hines. As it's not a particularly visual story, bar the climactic fight scene at the end, this is a good way to experience the serial. Sound quality is clear and easy to understand, and the story itself is very dialogue-driven.
2. The Loose Cannon Reconstruction: If the original Loose Cannon recon was the only one, I'd recommend the audio over the recon with no hesitation. Fortunately, Loose Cannon upgraded their reconstruction just a year or so before their current hiatus. With much clearer telesnaps and audio, the upgraded reconstruction is quite easy to view and enjoy. The fight scene remains a bit static, impossible to adequately cover in either recon form or audio. The original recon tried - imaginatively, but somewhat jarringly - to cover by using a clip from Mutiny on the Bounty. The newer one tries to cut between telesnaps and composite photos, which is less jarring but also less dynamic.
Given the dialogue-driven nature of the story, there's no clear winner for me between audio and recon. The official CD has clearer audio; the recon has the advantage of the visuals, albeit in stills, as well as a brief prologue detailing the historical Battle of Culloden, thus placing the story in a bit of context. Individual preference of narrated audio versus telesnap reconstruction is probably the best guide for which to choose in this case.
Review Index
To receive new review updates, follow me:
On BlueSky:
On Threads:
No comments:
Post a Comment